Question:
18" shotgun barrel vs 28"?
anonymous
2014-01-08 06:16:22 UTC
The remington 870 I have has an 18.5" barrel on it. I'm aware most hunting and professional skeet shotguns have 28" barrels usually. My question is, does barrel length increase the range AND control the spread better? I guess what I'm trying to say is is it even possible to shoot skeet with an 18" barrel? I have access to an 870 28" barrel just fyi
Fifteen answers:
anonymous
2014-01-08 06:26:09 UTC
Barrel length has nothing to do with the pattern. The choke controls the pattern.



A short barrel will swing faster, which is not what you want when shooting skeet. Use your 28 inch barrel for skeet, and use a skeet or IC choke.
anonymous
2017-01-02 17:44:05 UTC
26 Vs 28 Shotgun Barrel
Dave B.
2014-01-08 07:48:29 UTC
It is a myth that the length of the shotgun's barrel will significantly affect the shot pattern. Although there would be a noticeable difference between a sawed-off barrel and a full-length hunting barrel, the difference between a 18.5" barrel and a 28" barrel is not very noticeable IF both are cylinder bore (no choke). The choke makes 95% of the difference. A choke on a shorter barrel will produce a basically identical pattern that the same choke on a longer barrel will.



In regard to range, I'm not sure if you're talking about effective range or the actual distance that the shot will travel. A tighter choke will increase effective range because it keeps the shot within a tighter circle at that range. At a certain point, shot becomes so spread out that a target cannot reliably be hit by it beyond that range. A tighter choke will have a longer effective range, and a cylinder bore (no choke) will have the shortest effective range.



So-called law enforcement or self defense barrels feature a cylinder bore. While it is commonly thought that this is to make the shot spread wider so that a target is easier to hit, this is not the case. Rather, humans are big targets, and at the range that law enforcement or self defense encounters typically happen, no choke is required. A barrel with a cylinder bore is simply less expensive to produce, and requires less maintenance to keep it clean.



The main function of a shotgun barrel's length is to affect the swing of the weapon. In self defense scenarios, being able to instantly point the gun is important. A short barrel maintains minimal momentum, and allows the user to quickly swing the gun and then stop on their intended target. Hunting shotguns frequently have barrels of 22-28". When hunting small, fast moving targets, the shooter does not aim at the target and then stop the gun, he "swings through" the target and pulls the trigger while the gun is moving. Shorter barrels (22") are ideal for hunting rabbits in brush and flushing birds such as quail at close range. A wider choke is often used since range will be fairly short, and a wider shot pattern can increase the chances of a hit. Longer barrels (28") are usually used for birds flying overhead, where the gun will be swung more slowly. A tighter choke is often used to increase the effective range to help reach more distant targets.
?
2014-01-08 16:07:34 UTC
Barrel length has nothing to do with pattern or range. Longer guns have a longer sighting plane and swing/ follow targets more smoothly, and are therefore better suited for targets at longer ranges(geese, ducks,), but their pattern is no tighter than a short barreled gun with the same choke. Short barreled guns get on target faster and are easier to maneuver in tight quarters. These qualities are excellent in a home/self defense firearm, but also for certain types of hunting(Squirrel, rabbit, grouse)



As to skeet, I've never shot skeet, but I can't imagine any reason an 18.5" barrel couldn't work, but your technique would probably need to be different than with a longer barrel.
Lime Green Medic
2014-01-08 16:58:17 UTC
I've shot skeet with an 18.5" barrel, a 19" barrel, and a 20" barrel. It was pretty obvious I couldn't hit much, but we had fun. I do much better with a 24, 26, or 28 inch barrel. I tend to stick with the 26 inch, myself. On an old recoil-operated gun, because I'm a glutton for punishment.
Venice
2015-08-07 04:03:53 UTC
This Site Might Help You.



RE:

18" shotgun barrel vs 28"?

The remington 870 I have has an 18.5" barrel on it. I'm aware most hunting and professional skeet shotguns have 28" barrels usually. My question is, does barrel length increase the range AND control the spread better? I guess what I'm trying to say is is it even possible to shoot...
anonymous
2014-01-08 06:24:18 UTC
A 28 inch barrell will increase your range from an 18 inch barrell exactly 10 inches.

Barrell lenght advantage dates to the usage of black powder, where it could be a factor.



I've shot (unregistered trap and skeet) with a field gun having a barrell lenght of 24 inches successfully and had great time.
rodriguezperez
2016-11-14 05:09:25 UTC
18 Inch Shotgun
John de Witt
2014-01-08 14:48:04 UTC
The advantage of the long barrel isn't in range or pattern. It's a little about how the gun swings, but even more about the sight plane. Having the longer distance to the front bead simply means you'll hit what you're shooting at more often.
Mr.357
2014-01-10 19:18:25 UTC
The choke is what controls the spread of the shot. It is the last 3" of the barrel. The other 15.5-25 inches just increases the velocity. Some people like a long gun for its higher moment of inertia. I prefer a short fast gun.
anonymous
2014-01-08 06:18:40 UTC
YES. With a longer barrel the shot is kept together longer and has more energy. The "choke" at the end of the barrel also determines how the shot stays together. Some barrels have a choke you can manually change... other barrels are just MADE as a certain choke. My mossberg has a 31" inch barrel with full choke (I cannot change it, it was made that way).



The 18" barrel is more for CQB (close quarters battle) or home defense, NOT hunting.
John J. S
2014-01-08 16:33:14 UTC
1" spread for every meter the shot travel, so the 28" barrel is for hunting/target shooting. the 18" barrel is for self-defense/tactical (Military & Police) use.



The exception is the18" deer or rifled barrel which is exclusively for shooting slugs.
anonymous
2014-01-08 16:25:09 UTC
I have a Mossberg 500 with an 18.5" but it's not really a hunting weapon.
?
2014-01-08 06:23:19 UTC
Yes the longer barrel increases range and keeps the spread condensed longer...you definitely want the longer barrel...I duck hunt with an 870 wingmaster made in the 50's that my Dad used for goose hunting....I don't know the measurement but it's a long one....and it will reach out and down a duck at a good distance.
Space Cowboy
2014-01-08 08:00:06 UTC
My answer is the same as the one i gave you before ( i think it was you ) Long barrel....hunting etc....short barrel....defence.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...